Pimento Cheese Recipe - The Seasoned Mom (2024)

Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links. I may earn a small commission for my endorsem*nt, recommendation, testimonial, and/or link to any products or services from this website.

It doesn’t get more Southern than an old fashioned pimento cheese recipe. What a treat! This simple spread is made with just three ingredients: sharp cheddar cheese, mayonnaise, and diced pimentos. Serve it as an easy snack or appetizer with crackers or vegetables, in sandwiches, on burgers, in grits, in quesadillas, and more. It’s creamy, sharp, and very cheesy!

I was raised on pimento cheese, since it’s one of my mom’s all-time favorite foods. While I’ve tried zillions of versions over the years, this particular homemade pimento cheese recipe is the best I’ve ever tasted. An added bonus? You only need 3 ingredients and about 10 minutes of prep to stir together your own batch!

What’s Pimento Cheese?

A pimento (also spelled pimiento) is a variety of large, red, heart-shapedchili pepperthat’s typically 3-4 inches long and 2-3 inches wide. The flesh of the pimento is sweet and more aromatic than that of a redbell pepper.While some varieties of pimentos are spicy, the type used in pimento cheese is definitely not.

Pimento cheese is popular in the cuisine of the Southern United States, and is a spread or relish made by combining cheese, mayonnaise, and pimentos. It’s often called the “pâté of the south,” “Carolina caviar,” and “the caviar of the South,” and is typically served with crackers or vegetables, or spread between pieces of bread to make sandwiches. It has a creamy taste (from the mayo), but a chunky texture from the grated cheese and diced pimentos.

While some versions include additional ingredients such as horseradish,cream cheese,hot sauce,Worcestershire sauce, cayenne pepper, paprika, garlic powder, onion powder, jalapeños, onions, garlic, or dill pickles, our family agrees that the classic combination of just sharp cheddar, mayonnaise, and pimentos is the absolute best. Pimento cheese is not spicy, but instead tastes like a rich, creamy sharp cheddar spread.

Ingredients

This is just a quick overview of the ingredients that you’ll need for this easy pimento cheese recipe without cream cheese. As always, specific measurements and step-by-step instructions are included in the printable recipe box at the bottom of the post.

• Cheddar cheese: I prefer sharp cheddar cheese, but you can substitute with mild cheddar or extra-sharp cheddar cheese — whatever you like!
• Mayonnaise: use a high-quality full-fat mayo, since this is an important ingredient in your cheese spread. We like Duke’s brand best.
• Diced pimentos: just a little 4-ounce jar of the pre-diced pimentos goes straight into the bowl. You don’t even have to strain off the liquid from the jar!

How to Make Pimento Cheese

This three ingredient recipe couldn’t be easier! An old fashioned Southern pimento cheese recipe doesn’t require a hand mixer, stand mixer, or any other fancy equipment, and you don’t even need to wash too many dishes at the end. Just a box grater, a spoon, and some elbow grease will do the trick!

1. Grate about 1 pound of sharp cheddar cheese by hand or with a food processor, and then transfer it to a large bowl.
2. In a separate bowl, stir together the mayonnaise and the pimentos (with their juices).
3. Add the mayonnaise mixture to the grated cheese and stir to combine. Season with salt and pepper, and then refrigerate until you’re ready to serve!

Serving Suggestions

There are so many different ways to enjoy this Southern staple. Here are a few ways to serve the delicious spread:

• On top of crackers
• Spread inside celery sticks or as a dip for carrot sticks and other vegetables
• As a filling for a grilled cheese sandwich, or spread inside other sandwiches — including the classic Southern tomato sandwich or a BLT.
• Scooped with tortilla chips or other corn chips like Fritos
• Mashed with yolks for deviled eggs
• Stirred into grits
• Rolled up in tortillas and sliced as pinwheels for appetizers
• As a topping on hamburgers or hotdogs
• Melted inside quesadillas
• Or just slather it on a slice of white bread whenever the craving strikes!

Storage

• Make Ahead: You can prepare the pimento cheese up to 3 or 4 days in advance. Store the cheese spread in an airtight container in the fridge until ready to serve.
• Leftovers will keep in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to 1 week.
• Do not freeze pimento cheese, since mayonnaise tends to separate when it’s thawed.

Recipe Variations

• I use a jar of diced pimentos for a shortcut, but you can also use whole pimentos and dice them yourself into small pieces. Remember to reserve the liquid that the pimentos are packed in.
• Depending on your taste preferences, you can add 1-2 tablespoons of grated Vidalia onion to the pimento cheese, stir in minced jalapeno peppers, cayenne or hot sauce for a spicy kick, or add dill pickle relish for a briny finish. Some folks like to add garlic powder, minced green olives, cherry peppers, or other spices to their pimiento cheese; however, we think that the basic recipe is best!
• This recipe yields a large amount of pimento cheese spread (about 3 1/2 cups). If you are serving a smaller crowd, you can cut all of the ingredients in half to prepare a smaller batch.

Tips for the Best Pimento Cheese Recipe

• Since you’re only using three ingredients in this recipe, it’s really important to choose the highest quality cheese and mayonnaise that you can find. Grab a really great block of sharp cheddar — that’s the flavor that you will taste the most!
• Do not use pre-shredded cheese from a package. It’s best if you grate the cheese by hand or in a food processor just before using.
• Allow the pimento cheese to sit on the counter for about 30 minutes before serving. This will make it softer and easier to spread.
• If you’re preparing pimento cheese sandwiches, you’ll need approximately ⅓ – ½ cup of the cheese spread per sandwich. This recipe will make about 6-7 sandwiches. For 10 -15 sandwiches, for instance, you’ll need to double the recipe. For 50 sandwiches, you would need about 25 cups of pimento cheese spread (or about 7 batches of this recipe).

More Appetizers to Try

• Shrimp co*cktail
• Crab Stuffed Mushrooms
• 5-Ingredient Spinach Dip
• 10-Minute Holiday Crab Dip
• 3-Ingredient Southern Cheese Straws Appetizer

This recipe was originally published in June, 2020. The photos were updated in October, 2022.